On Wednesday, October 6, 2010, three justices of the Sixth Court of Appeals will be in Bonham to hear argument in the case of Cory Don Louis v. State of Texas. The hearing will be at the County Court at Law at 210 South Main Street, Bonham and will begin at 10 a.m.
In March, 2008, citizens of Fannin County were shocked to discover the brutal death of 2-year-old Channing (Chase) Matthew. Chase had been viciously beaten with a belt by his mother’s boyfriend, Cory Don Louis. Then his mother, Danielle Cuba, kicked him in the head and hung him by his arms in a closet. In May, 2009, a Fannin County jury convicted Chase’s stepfather, Cory Don Louis, of Capital Murder.
Although Capital Murder is an offense punishable by death, the Fannin County Criminal District Attorney’s office opted not to pursue the death penalty and Louis was sentenced to serve life in prison without the possibility of parole.
Louis filed his appeal with the Sixth Court of Appeals in Texarkana, Texas. Under Texas law, every person convicted of a criminal offense (other than those punishable only by a fine) is entitled to appeal his or her conviction. An appeal is not a new trial, and no evidence is presented. Rather, it is an opportunity for the convicted to complain about errors of law in the original trial or to allege the evidence presented at trial was insufficient to sustain the conviction. Louis has alleged 12 errors of law were committed by the trial court and has additionally claimed the evidence supporting his conviction is insufficient.
Ordinarily, an appellate court reviews a case based on the record of the trial, including the evidence presented, and the arguments contained in the parties’ briefs. Occasionally, an appellate court will ask the parties to argue certain points or issues in person, and will direct questions to the individual attorneys to clarify the arguments or points of law relevant to the case. Typically this is done at the appellate courthouse, which in the sixth appellate district is in Texarkana.
In this case, however, the court has taken the unusual step of traveling to hear oral argument. In addition to the Louis case, the court will hear argument in three other cases unrelated to Fannin County. Argument will last less than one hour in each case, though it is not known what order the cases will be heard. The hearings are open to the public, though because of the graphic subject matter in the Louis case it is recommended children do not attend.